Renters win eviction case: Judge overturns eviction case against mobile-home park renters-rights activists

Thursday, November 5, 2009
Anita Burke
Mail Tribune

Supporters of an Eagle Point woman who has
fought rent increases in mobile home parks whooped in the elevator and
applauded in front of the courthouse after Jackson County Circuit Court
Judge Lisa Greif dismissed an eviction case against Monika and John
Sayre Wednesday.

Monika Sayre organized a
homeowners association to contest rent increases at Butte Crest Park in
Eagle Point this year and advocated for rent control at the Legislature
during the 2009 session. She and others called the eviction summons
that park owner Follett Investment Properties Inc., of Gold River,
Calif., filed against her and her husband last week harassment for her
activities.

"They think I'm a rabble-rouser," she said with a grin.

Peter
Ferris, executive director of Oregon Manufactured Homeowners United,
said he had personally experienced eviction attempts for his activism
and now saw the same thing happening to the Sayres.

"It
is so courageous what she is doing," he said. "The seniors in so many
parks want to keep a low profile. She is an inspiration for so many."

More
than two dozen supporters from mobile home parks in Eagle Point, Shady
Cove, Phoenix, Rogue River and Grants Pass attended Sayre's court
appearance Wednesday.

Medford attorney Eric
Stark, representing the park owners, filed to dismiss the case. He
declined to comment after the judge acted.

Outside
the courtroom, Sayre said she had inadvertently underpaid her family's
space rent by $5 several months this summer — submitting checks for
$420 rather than the $425 owed under a rent increase enacted in July.
Her October payment was late, but her payment included a late fee, she
said.

She said the company held her checks for August and October, then claimed she hadn't paid.

She and Ferris said she would seek the return of her uncashed checks, then write a new check for the total amount owed.

Kathie
Campbell, Follett's regional manager in Gold River, Calif., said in a
phone interview that partial payments received from Sayre were credited
to the wrong month, prompting the eviction notice. She denied Sayre's
account of the events, but said tenants' right to privacy prevented her
from discussing the case.

Campbell said she
couldn't respond to the advocates' claims that the eviction might be
politically motivated. A new eviction notice will be filed, she said.

Campbell referred questions to a Portland attorney, Amy Barnhouse, who was unavailable for comment Wednesday afternoon.

"This was mismanaged by the manager from the get-go, but the corporation was willing to evict the Sayres," Ferris said.

He encouraged the gathered park residents to demand receipts so they have a record of each rental payment.

He
also asked for their support for a rent-justification bill that would
empower park residents to appeal space-rental increases to an
arbitrator. Such a program would provide a tool for people to combat
steep increases often proposed by out-of-state corporations that own
numerous mobile home parks, he explained.

"People
aren't looking for a free lunch," said Denny Taylor, who lives in a
Shady Cove park with his wife. "We just want fair treatment. This is a
human-rights issue, not just property rights."

Rep.
Peter Buckley, one of the backers of a rent-control bill that stalled
in committee this year, stopped by to congratulate the Sayres and was
greeted with applause.

Reach reporter Anita Burke at 776-4485, or e-mail aburke@mailtribune.com.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.    

Help build power for renters' rights: